still think it's too extreme.   Why must people be deprived of listening to music for free AT ALL? Then we could also agree that people have no right to read a book for free or to look at a painting reproduction for free? 

I still think that Sean's words are right and he doesn't sound extreme at all.
According to your logic, artists should give away everything and to die from the hunger. Yes, of course, artists do the art for people, but since it's their work, they have to be compensated. It was ALWAYS the case.

Actually people always listent to the music for free on the radio (if I'm not mistaken, it was said that artists used to get the compensation for that), people can attend free concerts if such are hold. And it was ALWAYS the case. ALWAYS!
Reproductions. Where do you usually see the reproductions? Special book editions, magazines....you pay for them! You buy them to see! With the internet occured in our lives, all of that lost the adequate regulation. People got the access to anything. And hardly many of artists get the compensation for their works.

Our Soviet motto was "Art belongs to people". Art shouldn't be luxury items for the well-off only. Ability and necessity to consume "spiritual food" distinguishes people from animals. Should we consume only material things if we don't have spare money? What's SO wrong in listening to something on YouTube (it's not people's fault that there's nothing worth listening on official radio channels!) to call these people criminals?

Yes, I can agree that Art belongs to people. But our soviet elite in the process of making such slogans didn't take into account that we live in the era of capitalism. Even if there was a socialism or communism, people would have to pay something to access the art. Or just do things to gain such access. And may be the society would be different. By the way, Marx in his marxist theory emphasizes that every person will be developed as an artist. Of course, you can decide to show people something for free or not. But the artist as the profession will always remain with the consiequences that you will have to pay.